Themes for the "In" Crowd by Percy Faith
Source: http://audiopreservationfund.org.License: All Rights Reserved.
The color is off, but this is the only large image I could find.
The designer is uncredited, but it is likely Bob Cato or John Berg who were art directors at Columbia at the time and who loved usingNesbitt's Gothic.
Source: http://audiopreservationfund.org.License: All Rights Reserved.